UN Security Council Divided Over ICC Role in Libya as War Crimes Trial Nears

UN Security Council Divided Over ICC Role in Libya as War Crimes Trial Nears

November 19, 2026 | By Semahegn Nigatu

The United Nations Security Council has split over the International Criminal Court’s role in Libya, with several members defending its pursuit of accountability while the United States and Russia questioned its jurisdiction and legitimacy, as proceedings against a former Libyan prison official move towards trial.

The divisions emerged during a Council briefing on Wednesday, nearly 16 years after the body referred the situation in Libya to the ICC in 2011.

The Court’s Acting Prosecutor, Mame Mandiaye Niang, told the Council that proceedings against Khaled Mohamed Ali el Hishri, a former Libyan prison official accused of committing atrocities at Mitiga Prison in Tripoli, marked progress towards accountability for victims.

On July 16, an ICC pre-trial chamber confirmed 17 war crimes charges against El Hishri, including murder, torture, persecution and rape. His trial is scheduled to begin in May 2027.

Niang said investigators were also pursuing alleged crimes committed between 2014 and 2020, as well as abuses against migrants in Libya.

He addressed the Council remotely, saying this was due to sanctions imposed by the US government. Despite the restrictions and other political pressures, he said the Court continued to make progress in its investigations.

Niang also raised concerns about another ICC suspect, Osama Elmasry Njeem, who he said reportedly remained free to meet officials and other individuals despite information about his detention in Libya. He urged cooperation to ensure the Court's arrest warrants were executed.

The briefing exposed divisions among Council members over the Court's jurisdiction, sanctions imposed against it and the balance between international accountability and Libya's judicial sovereignty.

Denmark, France and the United Kingdom defended the ICC's work and criticised sanctions against the institution.

France described the forthcoming trial as a signal that those responsible for serious crimes would face accountability, arguing that the Court's work was being conducted with the assistance of Libyan authorities rather than against the country's sovereignty.

The UK warned that measures restricting the Court's operations risked weakening international efforts to prosecute serious crimes.

The US representative reiterated Washington's opposition to the ICC exercising jurisdiction over countries without their consent. He said the US had maintained the same objections to the Court for nearly three decades, while acknowledging the need for accountability for serious human rights abuses in Libya, including violations in detention centres.

Russia called for the Security Council to withdraw its 2011 referral of the Libyan situation to the ICC. Its representative accused the Court of pursuing a politicised approach and selectively prosecuting individuals, while failing to address alleged abuses linked to the 2011 NATO intervention in Libya.

China and Bahrain emphasised the importance of national ownership and strengthening Libya's judicial institutions. Somalia said Libyan leadership in addressing justice should take precedence, supported by regional and African mechanisms.

Pakistan, which is not a party to the Rome Statute establishing the ICC, said it supported credible and impartial accountability for serious international crimes. Representatives of the Democratic Republic of the Congo and Panama welcomed progress in the Court's investigations and engagement with survivors and civil society.

Several Council members also called on Libyan authorities to cooperate with the Court, particularly in executing outstanding arrest warrants and protecting victims and witnesses.

Liberia said outstanding warrants remained unexecuted and urged Libya to respond to requests for assistance. Greece and Colombia stressed that victims should remain central to the judicial process, including through protection for witnesses and the safe participation of migrant survivors.

The dispute comes as the ICC seeks to advance its investigations into crimes committed in Libya amid continuing questions over cooperation between the Court and national authorities. The Council's November briefing highlighted the competing positions over how international justice should be pursued while respecting national sovereignty.

Source: FSX Business